Susan Smith makes second bid for parole in 1994 drowning deaths

COLUMBIA, S.C. — Susan Smith is set to appear before a South Carolina parole board this Thursday, marking her second attempt at release in two years. Smith is serving a life sentence for the 1994 drowning deaths of her two young sons in Union, S.C.

The case drew national attention more than 30 years ago when Smith initially claimed a Black man had carjacked her vehicle with her children inside.

After nine days of searching, investigators learned she had lied to cover up the drowning of 3-year-old Michael and 1-year-old Alex in John D. Long Lake.

Kevin Brackett, now the 16th Circuit Solicitor, served as a prosecutor on the case in 1994. He remembered rushing to the lake after detectives uncovered the cover-up and crews pulled the vehicle from the water.

“Every single time I pass the entrance to the boat ramp, I think about that night,” Brackett said. “And you know I mean it was horrifying.”

Investigators revealed that Smith had loaded old wedding photos into the car, strapped her sons into the back seat and allowed the vehicle to roll into the lake. Prosecutors said her primary motive was her desire to start a new relationship with a man who did not want children.

“Really, when it comes down to just sheer brazenness, you know. Look you right in the eye and lie to your face. There’s nobody that can compete with Susan; she is in a class by herself,” Brackett said. “It was selfish. She really just ... she wanted to shed her old life and hopefully move into this new life with this man. So she really didn’t care about the boys at all.”

During the nine-day search in 1994, Smith made public appeals for the return of her children, pleading, “Please bring my kids back. Please.” The revelation of her involvement shocked the Union community where Smith grew up.

A Union resident whose family knew Smith recalled the impact on the town. “She grew up in the community with my mom and my parents and my family,” the resident said. “And it was really shocking initially because people who knew her worked with her; that was not something that they expected.”

Under South Carolina state law, inmates sentenced for certain offenses become eligible to request parole every two years after reaching eligibility.

Former lead prosecutor Tommy Pope, now a state lawmaker, will attend the hearing to formally oppose Smith’s petition alongside David Smith, the father of Michael and Alex.

Pope questioned whether Smith has expressed genuine remorse during her decades in prison. “I don’t think she sits around thinking about Michael and Alex. I think she sits around thinking about how this has affected what she’d like to do. You know,” Pope said.

Pope noted that outcomes before a parole board remain uncertain despite strong opposition. “I always always tell people that you know the parole board to me is kind of like a jury,” Pope said. “You know, it’s made up of people, and you never know what they cling to and what they reject. And so I am hopeful that that’s not the case that she would be released. But again, I don’t take it for granted that she’ll remain incarcerated.”