CMS strategy committee meets to tackle governance and trust issues

This browser does not support the video element.

CHARLOTTE — The Charlotte-Mecklenburg Schools board’s newly formed Board Strategy, Governance and Operations Committee held its first meeting Tuesday night as part of ongoing efforts to restore trust in the district following months of controversy, internal strife, a state investigation and the firing of its former superintendent.

The committee was established to evaluate district operations, improve governance and align strategies with school system goals.

Members are working toward a Jan. 27 deadline to present a comprehensive list of recommendations for a full board vote.

The state Board of Education gave CMS several deadlines to show how it plans to take corrective action following recent leadership turmoil.

A board member noted that the district views those deadlines as a compliment because members had already begun working on improvements prior to the state’s directive.

The committee’s first meeting follows a Nov. 12 letter from North Carolina State Board of Education Chair Eric Davis to CMS Board Chair Dee Rankin.

In the letter, Davis requested multiple corrective action measures, including a governance training plan, a financial and procedural controls report, specific steps to improve board working relationships, a plan to conduct a superintendent search, and bi-weekly progress updates.

Committee Chair Shaimaye Haynes stated that planning for the committee actually began in early October, before the state letter arrived.

Haynes explained that the panel aims to right the ship and address governance issues directly. “I believe we do have some course correction that we need to make,” Haynes said. She urged the board to “just take this opportunity in a crisis to do something positive.”

Board member Stephanie Sneed emphasized the necessity of updating board practices and operational procedures. “I think that what we realize is that processes, operations, as well as governance have to evolve with the people and the times,” Sneed said.

Other board members highlighted the importance of shared values and reflection. Board member Dr. Melissa Balknight noted that while board members do not always need to agree, “it is critical in my opinion that our board is aligned in their core values.”

Board member Dr. Charlitta Hatch welcomed the evaluation process, saying, “I love that we had an opportunity to be tested and now we can look back at what we learned, what we need to revisit, what we might need to strengthen.”

Addressing public skepticism, Haynes stressed that the board must demonstrate steady progress over time to rebuild trust. “You just have to stay consistent, and you have to stay dedicated and show proof,” Haynes said.

Meanwhile, CMS Board Vice Chair Liz Monterrey-Duval, who was originally expected to serve on the new committee, is no longer participating after determining she had overcommitted herself, according to Haynes.

The district has already begun the search for a new superintendent. The committee will continue its work to finalize recommendations ahead of the Jan. 27 board vote.