PEA ISLAND, N.C. — Anyone who’s lived, worked and traveled along Hatteras Island knows the area is seeing some problems. A nor’easter in late September buckled the pavement on NC-12, leading to a $1.7 million repair. Then weeks later, another nor’easter destroyed the same spot.
So far, the North Carolina Department of Transportation says the repairs could cost another $850,000.
For the second time in a month, NCDOT is spending millions to fix this same stretch of road. The agency knows it’s a problem spot but a permanent fix that’s going to take more than dunes.
“People ask why we’re trying to put the road right back in the ocean,” said NCDOT Division Engineer Ronnie Sawyer.
After a big storm, Sawyer says it can feel that way. Again and again, the same stretch of Highway 12 near the Pea Island Visitor’s Center gets washed out, flooded, or covered in sand.
“Highway 12 is our lifeline. When that gets hit we all feel it,” said Jeff Dawson of Buxton, North Carolina.
Dawson owns Fattys Eatery about 30 miles south.
When the highway closes, he can’t drive off the island, and tourists can’t get to him.
“We were cut off almost all of October. My employees need a paycheck. I need money to pay my employees,” Dawson said.
Sawyer says the DOT works to reopen the road as quickly as possible after storms but everyone agrees things need to change.
“Part of that is the nature of a barrier island. It moves over time. Our road is in one place and our barrier island tends to move,” Sawyer said.
In the near term, that means moving further inland. NCDOT submitted a request to the Fish and Wildlife Service to reroute that section of road. That would mean moving the visitor’s center parking lot and filling in some of the wetlands. Sawyer says even that, though, would be a temporary fix.
“If you’re really talking about true long-term solutions, most of them are bridges anywhere from three to 11 or 12 miles,” Sawyer said.
The Solving Access for NC-12 in Dare County, or SAND, study is looking at that possibility.
Sawyer says the biggest question isn’t whether to build a bridge but where.
“You start looking at erosion rates, prediction of where the shoreline’s gonna be 20, 30, 50 years, then it gets a little more complicated on where to land the bridge,” Sawyer said.
In the meantime, Dawson says folks like him hold their breath anytime a storm or high tide threatens to cut them off.
“You’re just sitting on a rug waiting for someone to yank it out from under you all the time,” Dawson said.
Public comment on the Highway 12 relocation plan is open until next Tuesday. The longer-term study on a bridge is going until Dec. 20.
Since September of last year, 20 homes have collapsed along the Outer Banks shoreline.
North Carolina lawmakers introduced three Senate bills in June that would provide solutions for protecting property along the coast from beach erosion.
©2026 Cox Media Group





