CHAPEL HILL, N.C. — The Daily Tar Heel student newspaper sparked outrage at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill after publishing satirical articles on April Fools’ Day regarding immigration enforcement and diversity initiatives.
The publication has since removed the controversial content and issued an apology following intense criticism from student leaders and campus organizations, the Charlotte Observer reports.
The articles were part of the newspaper’s annual April Fools’ edition but were not clearly labeled as satire in the initial newsletter distribution. Campus groups condemned the content as “unsettling” and “harmful” during a period of declining Black enrollment and administrative changes at the university.
One satirical article featured a headline claiming federal authorities ordered Alcohol Law Enforcement in Chapel Hill to be replaced with U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents. The story alleged that ICE was being sent to a “high-crime destination” in North Carolina.
[ READ: UNC Charlotte meteorology program grows with new course, equipment ]
Devin Duncan, the incoming UNC student body president, said the report caused immediate alarm. He said he received texts on Wednesday morning asking if agents were actually arriving on campus.
“I had almost thought the Daily Tar Heel had been hacked,” Duncan said. “To read some of those articles, they were very unsettling, disrespectful and insensitive.”
Another headline stated “UNC brings back DEI — for whites,” referring to diversity, equity and inclusion programs.
Adolfo Alvarez, the current student body president at UNC, said the joke was offensive given the current political climate.
“At a moment when Black enrollment at UNC is declining, and DEI initiatives are under systemic attack, joking about ‘DEI for whites’ is a slap in the face,” Alvarez said. “It mocks the students who are currently fighting just to feel like they belong on this campus.”
Other satirical items included a “two-stadium solution” for the Dean Smith Center and a report that recently fired men’s basketball coach Hubert Davis was searching for a summer internship.
Campus organizations, including Students United for Immigrant Equality and the Black Student Movement, released statements condemning the articles. Students also used TikTok and Instagram to express frustration with the content.
[ READ: Advocacy group to speak on ICE arrest at Charlotte health department ]
Alli Pardue, editor-in-chief of The Daily Tar Heel, published an official apology the same day the articles appeared. She acknowledged that the publication failed to consider the impact of its editorial choices.
“While we stand by our belief in the importance of satire writing, we undeniably missed the mark here — big time,” Pardue told the Observer. “We did not package this content with enough consideration and care and it caused real harm to the very communities we work to uplift and platform.”
University officials said that the Daily Tar Heel is an independent news organization not affiliated with UNC-Chapel Hill.
Phoebe Martel, an investigative reporter for the newspaper, said she was disturbed by the content. She noted that while the intent may have been to mock those in power, the execution failed to translate that way.
“Gaza and ICE, these are very sensitive and deep personal topics for people,” Martel said. “I hope that they all learn something from this.”
Meredith D. Clark, an associate professor of race and political communication at the Hussman School of Journalism, noted that political satire is difficult to perform well. She said there was a “missed connection” between the students’ knowledge and their empathy for those directly affected by the topics.
[ READ: Judge blocks ending of government support for DEI programs, citing free-speech rights ]
“There’s a difference in being knowledgeable about a state of affairs and then being empathetic to the people who are connected to it quite directly,” Clark said.
Clark said student journalists face unique challenges because they learn their profession in a public “arena” where mistakes are amplified. She said these students must deal with consequences in a way other practitioners do not because their lapses in judgment are visible to the entire community.
Meanwhile, The Duke Chronicle at Duke University also published satirical content on Wednesday, covering topics such as the Jan. 6 Capitol riot, campus protests and sexual harassment education.
WATCH: High gas prices don’t deter spring break travelers
This browser does not support the video element.