Federal agency plans tighter regulation of ‘buy now, pay later’ companies

CHARLOTTE — More people are starting to shop using the “buy now, pay later” option, which became popular during the pandemic. These businesses don’t have to follow as many rules as other lenders, but Action 9 investigator Jason Stoogenke says a federal agency plans to change that, which could mean major changes for shoppers.

Joyous Watson said she bought pants and shirts for about $47. She used one of the most popular “buy now, pay later” lenders, Afterpay.

“(I’ve) used them before. Had great experiences,” she said.

“Buy now, pay later” lenders pay for your item and you pay them back, usually in four installments. There’s no interest, but there are late fees.

“It’s pretty more convenient, I guess, than buying it on credit, or having to have your credit score pulled or something like that,” said Watson.

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau has concerns about “buy now, pay later.” The bureau says:

- It’s usually harder for you to dispute charges than when you use credit cards.

- Some lenders tack on multiple late fees on the same missed payment.

- Some track users’ shopping habits and sell the data.

- Lenders tend to say yes to people who shouldn’t qualify, and who may already be racking up a lot of similar loans.

The CFPB is eyeing more rules to combat these concerns and treat these lenders more like credit card companies.

Watson said she never got her clothing order, but at last check, Afterpay still wanted its money and she didn’t want to rack up those late fees.

“It’s very frustrating because I do like to shop. I will say that. I like to shop,” she said.

You may expect her to be in favor of more regulation, but she isn’t so sure. She worries the lenders might make it harder for customers to land “Buy Now, Pay Later” loans.

Stoogenke asked Afterpay about both Watson’s situation and the idea of more regulation. The company emailed this response:

“Afterpay follows each individual merchant’s policies for returns and has no control or management over how merchants process their returns. Whether it’s for in-store or online purchases, returns are subject to the merchant’s policy and can typically be found on their website or by contacting them directly. When a customer makes a return and the merchant processes a refund, it will automatically be reflected in a customer’s payment schedule seen on their Afterpay portal, which can take up to 10 days to be reflected in their Afterpay account. Due to privacy purposes, Afterpay is unable to issue a refund to a shopper on behalf of the merchant.

“With this particular customer case, Afterpay was made aware of her situation and provided clarity that issues regarding shipping and delivery as well as returns and cancellations are managed by the merchant. Following this information, the Afterpay team provided additional support to the customer to help remedy her situation and submitted a dispute to the merchant on behalf of the customer. The complaint was eventually closed after the merchant confirmed a claim process was underway.

“In regards to the CFPB inquiry, Afterpay welcomes efforts to ensure that there are appropriate regulatory protections for consumers in the diverse BNPL industry, and that providers are meeting high standards and delivering positive consumer outcomes while protecting their data. Afterpay provides consumers with better transparency, lower costs, and better budgeting tools than traditional forms of credit and promotes responsible spending.

“Afterpay also promotes and enables responsible credit use by pausing accounts from future purchases if a payment is late, capping late fees, and not charging interest. These built-in safeguards mean that Afterpay customers are actually half as likely to be delinquent than credit card customers.”

VIDEO: Scammers are using more robotexts to target victims